Back to search
Reverse the Verse ·
Published on this date.2019-03-08
· 13 Q&As

Star Citizen: Reverse the Verse LIVE - What Makes A Helmet?

An artist sculpts a Banu helmet live in 3D, discussing how Banu culture, head shape, the horn and organic curved forms shape the design, and how helmets get put on. They also cover Wacom tablets, the Subscriber Vault and a female player character update for 3.5.

Transmission log

Full answers

We know the human style guides pretty well at this point. What kind of considerations do you have to, for lack of a better word, consider when doing a Banu helmet?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Some of it's just their culture. So what kind of things they pay attention to, especially when it comes to breathing apparatuses or shapes, or maybe they have a specific style that they like or that they're more accustomed to, or things like that. So obviously, you also have different head shapes. So their head shape is different than a human's head shape. It's similar, but it's got some other key features. So is that something that we want to try to hide, or is this something we want to try to emphasize with the design? So we could pretty quickly and easily start saying, if we want to keep this sort of Mohawk-y vibe, we can kind of run with that.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

It seems like there wouldn't be a functional purpose to having a visor at the top of your head like that.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

No, this is more of one of these kind of things where we'll be able to have a visor or a glass piece that you will be able to see through the canopy of it. But I'm kind of looking for, with this, what that shape could be and why they would need it to be a certain shape. You need so much extra headroom here, so changing the shape of the helmet. They might have a very unique look to their helmets. This might be something that you can tell from a distance is them.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

Does the horn have any particular significance, so that we might consider letting the horn protrude through the helmet? Somebody in the chat brought up the way the Coneheads would touch cones. Do Banu have any functionality or cultural significance to the horns? Do they touch horns? Do you want to be able to expose the horn easily without having to take off the entire helmet?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

To be honest, I don't really know. That's definitely a good cultural question.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
LoreCharacter & clothing

Right now you're experimenting with aesthetics more than function. At some point, I imagine we have to consider how the heck he puts this thing on.

TL;DRGetting a helmet on is a hard problem, and films often skip it by having the helmet simply appear when the script needs quick action; the team still has to work out how it functions.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Putting helmets on is always a challenging thing. Even in movies, a lot of the helmets you see don't actually... Even some of the stuff in movies like Interstellar: the helmets in Interstellar are so incredibly small that they don't actually fit on any of the actors' heads, as a classic astronaut helmet. So things we've got to figure out when it comes to the functionality of it for these characters is...

Going back to the function, some of these things don't exactly make sense how to get it on. Marvel movies lately have gone to the "oh, it's just a button and the helmet builds over the head."

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Yeah, it's just so easy, right? It's kind of one of those: we have this problem, and a lot of that stuff is built out of necessity for the script, actually. So when you see something like, we want to immediately get into an action scene, but they need to go fly in space or they need to do something, rather than spending the quick suit-up sequence time or whatever, it just turns into a "well, what if we just make it appear? How can we make it appear?" So those kind of conversations are pretty common, and we need this to go on very quickly. And it is just kind of an easy thing.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

What about the size of the Banu horn? Obviously, we haven't seen many Banu. Is the horn something that would change size between Banu?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

I think it would. It's definitely something we're playing with. A lot of the concepts that we've been showing are essentially... Whenever you start designing a race, it's like you do one first. It's hard to say. Even when you look at humans, if somebody were to draw one picture for what a human looks like, you'd only get one picture of one person. So this is sort of the snapshot of what we think one Banu would look like. It's not always about trying to define the entirety of the species. So right now, I think it would probably range in shape, size, color. We could do all different kinds of things with it that might make it more appealing or different.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
LoreCharacter & clothing

We know that the Banu, from what we've seen of ships like the Merchantman and the Defender, have a very organic look to their technologies. The thing that I'm noticing you're already doing is there aren't a lot of hard edges, like 45-degree angles, things that wouldn't occur in nature. Everything that you're doing right now is very curved, very flowing?

TL;DRThe Banu design deliberately avoids hard 45-degree edges, taking cues from natural and anatomical forms, using soft shapes whose lines ease into each other like muscle insertion lines.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Yeah, absolutely. And when you look at organic stuff or you use a lot of reference from nature, you can see that occasionally, but especially in animals... A very common thing, especially for general artists, is to look at anatomy; human anatomy especially is where you start. We were talking before about comic book movies and stuff before the show started, and a huge inspiration, I think, for a lot of people is comic books. And when you look at and you start drawing the human figure, there's not a lot of those hard lines just in general. But there's a different type of line, which is an insertion line. So that's basically where two muscles would meet. There is a separation line, but it's very natural looking rather than a 45-degree line. So that's kind of what I'm actually playing with here: we've got some softer shapes that have lines, but they're meeting each other in a way that's more of one side is kind of easing into that angle and one side is not.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
Art & graphicsLore

Are you using a Wacom tablet?asked by Typhoonie

He is using a Wacom tablet. Show him your pen.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

This is a Wacom 5 or 6 or something. I don't know which one this is.

Don't let the fact that the module in the program is called Lazy Mouse let you think that he's using a mouse.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Oh, yeah. You can. I have tried to sculpt with a mouse before. It's very difficult. The best thing about the pen is it's more of a natural pen stroke. It's more akin to drawing. Whereas if you're drawing with a mouse, it's a lot like drawing with a bar of soap, which I think is really difficult. Or chalk.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

Is there any concept art for the helmet you're making?asked by Typhoonie

We are making concept. This is what we call a 3D concept. So there is no prior art to this. You are watching the creation of a concept right now. Some artists concept in 2D, some artists concept in 3D.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

Is it even a remote possibility that the end product of this design will eventually end up in the game itself if he likes it and Chris likes it and other people like it?

TL;DRIt's possible the helmet makes it into the game, but many iterations are normally made and only one usually gets used, so they'll likely try plenty of other Banu helmet designs first.

That's the thing. If you're a subscriber, you have access to something called the Subscriber Vault. And in the Subscriber Vault, you can see dozens and dozens and dozens of concepts for ships that didn't make it to the Star Citizen universe, or versions of ships that did, but versions that we didn't use. So many, many concepts are created for any one particular design, and only one ever usually gets used. It's one of those things: when you buy one of those Art of Star Wars books or whatever, you can see two dozen different variations of what eventually became Kylo Ren. And you're just like, "Oh, wow, so many different designs. Oh, I love that one. That's the one I wanted."

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

It's pretty common. When you do concept art for movies, film, entertainment in general, especially on the art side, it's so common to do hundreds of iterations for one thing, and you have to accept, as part of the gig, part of what that job is, that only one's going to make it. So all your efforts and all your team's efforts are basically going to making the best possible thing. So is it possible that this helmet will go in? Yeah, it's totally possible, but we'll probably do plenty of other iterations on what a Banu helmet could look like before we really come to that resolution.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

Talking about Twitch Pacheco, who is one of the first fully realized female characters that we're seeing in the Persistent Universe, I'm seeing some questions about the female player character, which is scheduled to come online for 3.5. Is there a general update you can give us on that?

TL;DRThe female player character is on track for 3.5 with some bugs and fewer clothing options, though armor will match the male's and more clothing is planned for 3.6 and later.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Right now, it's definitely on track. One thing to note about the female player is that it's a massive feature. Obviously, we've been talking about it for a really long time. But the biggest thing about it is that there's so many different elements going into it from all different kinds of things we're doing right now. So we're having to adjust our shops, for example. So our shops are being adjusted because now you have multiple genders to choose from. So what is that experience like? Our character customizer's being overhauled because you have an additional gender. You have all the animations that are going to play, from just the basics of playing, all the gameplay stuff from shooting to flying ships to jumping; every possible animation that you have is going to need to be there for the female. So I guess what I'm getting at is there's so much in that that there will be some bugs. There will be some visual bugs. Maybe an animation isn't perfect, or some of the animations we haven't had the time to make a female version, and so we've just patched over the male version and we're using that. So there's going to be some stuff that we want to iterate on through the rest of, definitely, this year, to get it to a more final state. But I think for myself, looking at her as a feature, it's not worth a couple bugs of visual fidelity or shopping to put it off for another quarter, because you kind of get into this point of, "Oh, at the end of this quarter, this thing would be nice to have in. Oh, okay, we'll wait for that thing at the end of this quarter." So basically, for example, one of the big things is the female player is going to not have all of the clothing options that the male will have, because our tech team was hit very hard this quarter on our DNA work and our shop work and our character customizer work. So they haven't had the time to skin stuff this quarter, not as much as we would have wanted them to, right? And that basically just means they'll still have all the gameplay components and they'll be one-to-one there. But we had to make a choice of: is it nothing, or?

I just want to be really super clear on that. You're not saying that those options aren't coming.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

No, of course. They're coming.

It's just that, like you said in the Pacheco segment in yesterday's ATV, pursuing that fantastic hair for Pacheco, if it's not ready by 3.5, we're not going to let it stop us from putting Pacheco out in 3.5.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Exactly. We'll give her a hood. We'll find something else.

So it's not that we're not going to do every armor one-to-one and all these clothes one-to-one. It's just we're going to do as many as we can up to the release of 3.5 and then put it out with what's ready, and then continue to iterate on it after that.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Exactly. And right now the female will have all of the armors that the male has. So as far as what we're kind of calling gameplay clothing, where the armor has more gameplay — you can store weapons, you can do things in it, you can go into space — we'll be one-to-one. So that's something that we've definitely focused on.

Well, that was one of the tenets of moving to this quarterly date-based release system: we were no longer going to wait until we had everything to put something out. We hit these quarterly releases and we push out with what's ready to push out.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

So in 3.5, we'll have a set released for the female, and then in 3.6, I can guarantee we'll have more.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019

Do you normally work on a tablet like that or directly on a touch-sensitive monitor?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

I prefer tablet, actually. A lot of the artists here use Cintiqs, which is the sensitive monitors. There's other brands and stuff; Wacom is the biggest one. I like to use a tablet because, it sounds weird, but my hand gets in the way. So I don't like having...

The visual obstruction?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

Yeah. If you were to draw where my cursor is, my hand would be on it, which is fine, but I just prefer for it to not be there.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
Art & graphics

Have you ever designed in VR?

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

I have never designed in VR. It seems pretty cool from what I've seen. But I have never. My face would get sweaty. I've seen a lot of really good work off of it, though. So I would like to at some point. Seems like it'd be a fun experience, for sure. Even if it doesn't work for your workflow, I think it maybe puts you in a different perspective or frame of mind. It might be a good way to change up your workflow.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
Art & graphics

Do Banu have terrible hearing? Somebody in the chat said that.

I don't remember that. It's possible.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

It's possible. Maybe they need little hearing speakers. You can add little details in there. And that's kind of the fun stuff. I feel like their designs would be a little simpler overall, just because I think the organic nature leads to that, rather than having all kinds of crazy details.

They're saying, according to lore, Banu have bad hearing.

Josh HermanCharacter Art Director

I did not actually know that. I don't remember that part. I wonder if it was in a Lore Builder.

Reverse the Verse·
Published on this date.8 Mar 2019
LoreCharacter & clothing